The 2010 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, Part II: Considerations

August 26th, 2010

ChemBark MedallionI’ve always thought of the competition for the Nobel Prize in Chemistry as a beauty pageant for nerds, since: (i) people only pay attention for a couple of days a year, (ii) everyone has an opinion, but no one cares too much, and (iii) the judging is subjective as hell and based on nebulous criteria.

When you’ve got a stage full of perfect tens, how can you definitively identify the hottest and most talented?  You can’t, but you can wave your hands in a ridiculous manner.  Let’s do that.  Listed below are several factors that do or can enter consideration when picking Nobel winners:

Factors/Considerations

1.   Pulse — You can’t win the prize unless you’re alive.  Some believe that when even one important contributor to a discovery dies, it damages the odds of the rest of the group  (e.g., J.K. Stille died in the 1989 Sioux City plane crash, and cross-coupling reactions have never won despite their unquestioned importance and repeated calls for their recognition with a Nobel). 

2.  Merit of Discovery —  This one should also be obvious, but some people forget:  to win, you have to have made a profoundly important discovery or invention in chemistry.  You can’t just take any well-known, big-named chemist and expect her to get the prize.  It is very rare for a Nobel Prize to be awarded as a “lifetime achievement award” for a set of loosely-related projects rather than for one specific, important discovery or invention.  (Examples: many consider Woodward’s prize in 1965 and Corey’s in 1990 to be  of the lifetime-achievement variety.) 

3.  Maturity of Discovery — While it runs counter to the directions in Nobel’s will that the prize go to discoveries made “during the preceding year”, there is always a wait of at least a decade between an initial discovery and its recognition with a Nobel Prize.  This time lag is often much, much longer.  Many people are of the opinion that you must wait for a discovery and its field to mature before you can assess whether it deserves a prize.  The 1996  prize to fullerenes is often cited as having been given “too soon”, as these molecules haven’t had the impact in practical applications that many thought they would.

4.  Freshness of Discovery — While maturity is key, eventually you get to a point where a discovery is stale and its time for recognition has probably passed.  Sadly, I think Djerassi’s discovery of the birth control pill falls into this category.  (How the hell did both medicine and chemistry step over this one?)

5.  Collaborators: Previous Laureates — You don’t see prizes for similar discoveries, so if a particular scientist wins one, her close competitors and collaborators are almost certainly out of luck.  For instance, Ertl’s triumph in 2007 has a devastating effect on the odds of other people in his field (e.g., Gabor Somorjai—many regard it a travesty that Somorjai did not share in the prize that year).Math Chick is Unimpressed 

6.  Collaborators: Where n ≤ 3 — The prize can only be shared by three people in any given year.  Some believe that if more than three can make a good claim, the odds of the entire group will suffer.  Perhaps it’s too hard for the committee to judge who gets left out?  For instance, if a prize were to be awarded to cross-coupling reactions, what three chemists would/should share it?

7.  Variety — Many think the committee likes some variety in recognizing disciplines.  Before Ertl won in 2007, the last surface chemist to win the prize was the great Irving Langmuir in 1932.  Such temporal spacing can’t be encouraging to others in the field.  If this variety argument holds, relative to last year, the chances of seeing structural biology win again are low(er).

8.  Previous Awards — The rich get richer.  There is a correlation between winning awards such as the Lasker and Wolf and winning a Nobel.  You can glance down the lists yourself: 

Lasker Award in Basic Medical Research
Wolf Prize in Chemistry
Welch Award

9.  Like-ability/Politics — You always hear that “XXX will never win a prize because…”  “…he wants one too much” or “…he is a jerk” or “he is an egomaniac”.  Being personally disliked can do nothing but hurt a candidate’s chances, but by how much?  (ChemBark respectfully declines to list possible examples of point #9).

10.  Interdisciplinary Contenders — Many major discoveries are interdisciplinary in nature and have a shot at winning in two or more of the Nobel Prize categories.  Most structural and molecular biology contenders could easily be shoehorned into chemistry or medicine.  Because these types of projects stand good chances to win a prize in other fields, their odds to win in chemistry will be reduced. 

11.  Nationality Bias— Although more Americans have won Nobel Prizes in chemistry than any other nationality, many people are of the belief that there is an anti-American bias in awarding the prize.   You might be able to mount a good case with regard to instances where the committee awarded a prize for a discovery but either left out an American collaborator or selected a non-American scientist at the expense of an American.  For instance: Gabor Somorjai (omitted in 2007), Douglas Prasher (omitted in 2008 ), Thomas Katz (omitted in 20065), and Jack Roberts (omitted in 1991).  Americans might be able to mount an argument they are disproportionately shafted. 

12.  Community Perception — Across the country, people continually chat about who should or shouldn’t get a Nobel.  The “buzz” usually reaches its peak in September.  I’ve got to believe that the buzz one hears on the west coast is similar to the buzz on the east coast, and those are similar to the buzz in Stockholm.

13. The Internet (?) — Let’s face it: the first thing most of us do when analyzing any major decision is to collect as much pertinent information as efficiently as possible.  The Internet is a great tool for this job.  I’ve got to believe that at least some of the people involved in choosing the prizes have had a quick look through what people have had to say online.  Here’s a sampling of some predictions, opinions, and analysis from the blogosphere: 

ChemBark/Endless Frontier: 2006-1, 2006-2, 2006-3, 2007-1, 2007-2
In the Pipeline: 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009
Carbon-Bases Curiosities: 2007, 2008, 2009
The Chem Blog: 2008, 2009-1, 2009-2
The Sceptical Chymist: 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009 (includes ISI Thomson Reuters)
Curious Wavefunction: 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009

I’m sure I’m missing some posts on other great blogs.  Post your links in the comments.

Now, let’s go back to our 2007 list and mark it up accordingly:  green = Nobel winners, red = deceased (these two colors are given precedence), and blue= Lasker Award winners, purple = Wolf Prize winners, brown= Welch Award winners.

The Field (everything not listed below), 3-1
Molecular Studies of Gene Recognition, Ptashne, 15-1
Nuclear Hormone Signaling, Chambon/Evans/Jensen, 15-1
Fluorescent Probes/GFP, Tsien/Prasher/Shimomura, 15-1
Modern Surface Chemistry, Somorjai/Ertl/Whitesides/Nuzzo/+/–, 15-1
Transition-Metal-Catalyzed Cross-Couplings, Suzuki/Heck/Sonogashira/Tsuji/+/–, 17-1
Instrumentation/Techniques in Genomics, Venter/+, 19-1
Biological Membrane Vesicles, Rothman/Schekman/+, 19-1
Techniques in DNA Synthesis, Caruthers/Hood/+, 19-1
Molecular Structure of the Ribosome, Steitz/Moore/Yonath/+/–, 29-1
Telomeres & Telomerases, Blackburn/Greider/Szostak, 29-1
Application of Lasers to the Study of Chemical Reactions, Zare, 39-1
Bioinorganic Chemistry, Lippard/Holm/Gray/+/–, 39-1
Mechanistic Enzymology, Walsh/Knowles/Abeles, 49-1
Combinatorial Chemistry/DOS, Schreiber/+, 49-1
Pigments of Life, Battersby/+, 49-1
Global Warming, Thatcher/Gore, 99-1
Development of the Birth Control Pill, Djerassi, 99-1
Development of Chemical Biology, Schultz/Schreiber/+, 99-1
Molecular Modeling and Assorted Applications, Karplus/Houk/Schleyer/+/–, 99-1
Organic Synthesis, Evans/Danishefsky/Nicolaou/Ley/Trost/Stork/Wender/Kishi/+/–, 149-1
Fluorocarbons, Dupont/Curran/–, 199-1
Dendrimers, Frechet/Tomalia/+, 199-1
Application of NMR to Organic Chemistry, Roberts, 199-1
Understanding of Organic Stereochemistry, Mislow, 199-1
Mechanical Bonds and Applications, Sauvage/Stoddart/+, 199-1
Self-Assembly, Whitesides/Nuzzo/Stang/+/–, 199-1
Noble Gas Reactivity, Bartlett/+, 199-1
Tissue Engineering, Langer/+, 199-1
Contributions to Bioorganic Chemistry, Breslow/Eschenmoser/+, 199-1
Molecular Recognition, Dervan/+, 399-1
Development of Nanotechnology, Lieber/Whitesides/Alivisatos/Seeman/+/–, 399-1
Astrochemistry, Oka, 399-1
Zeolites, Flanigan, 399-1
Molecular Machines, Stoddart/Tour/+/–, 499-1
Studies in the Origin of Life, Miller/Orgel/+/–, 99999-1
 

So…a number of worthy candidates have cleared the queue, and fortunately, not many have died in the past three years.  The 2010 competition is as wide open a contest as I can remember.   One interesting fact: Pierre Chambon is the only person on this list to have been awarded the Lasker, Welch, and Wolf (but not a Nobel).   Is this his year?  (Oops…no Wolf.)

Next Nobel post:  Part III — New candidates and our revised rundown for 2010.


75 Responses to “The 2010 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, Part II: Considerations”

  1. Ken Says:

    How about people who have made real and profound impacts on the standard of living of millions, such as ACS Heroes of Chemistry?
    http://portal.acs.org/portal/acs/corg/content?_nfpb=true&_pageLabel=PP_SUPERARTICLE&node_id=1464&use_sec=false&sec_url_var=region1&__uuid=14fb5eca-51bb-4dfc-a7f5-bc73cee82d64

  2. Anonymous Says:

    I think you mean 2005 for Katz (although he also didn’t win it in 2006), and two of the three laureates were American.

  3. excimer Says:

    Fine Paul, if you won’t, I will: If anyone deserved a Nobel for their discoveries but didn’t get it because of #9 (politics and likability), it was F. A. Cotton. His work on metal-metal multiple bonds (and the discovery of compounds containing a quadruple bond), among other things, made him a serious contender, but damn if he didn’t piss a lot of people off when he was alive, too. (along those lines, don’t expect any MOF prize either, and not only because they don’t really do anything.)

  4. Paul Says:

    @Anonymous: Yep…2005. Corrected in post.

    @Excimer: Since it doesn’t seem like C&EN or any other news organization will do it, I wonder if Jeffrey Seeman will ever give an ACS talk about the details surrounding Cotton’s death. It sounded very, very shady.

  5. excimer Says:

    @Paul: I’m hoping, at the very least, they make a Law and Order episode out of it.

  6. Matt Says:

    Better yet, what would be the title for that episode?

    Paul, I would argue that fullerenes aroused the public’s curiosity and interest in science centered on the field of “nano”. Now, you can argue what deserves to be called nanotechnology, but I always felt that fullerenes (and Richard Smalley) were the public face of this new science. So, personally, I’ve always thought that they deserved it.

  7. Paul Says:

    @Matt: I also think that the ’96 prize was intended, in part, to stimulate interest in nano, both in the public and in the scientific community. At least, I’ve got to believe that in order to rationalize that year’s decision. While you often see such a prize in the peace category, and sometimes in medicine, you really don’t see it that often in chemistry. Perhaps that committee was on a bit of a roll after the ’95 prize to Molina, Rowland, and Crutzen.

  8. Paul Says:

    @Ken: There is certainly a bias against industrial chemists in terms of winning Nobels. Organizations win Nobel Peace Prizes all of the time, so why not companies?

    You’d think that with all of the cool materials DuPont has given us, they should be right up there.

  9. phthor Says:

    Robert Abeles died in 2000, so that’s not happening.

    Anyway, it should probably have been Westheimer but his name would have been in red since 2007.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Westheimer

    Another selection point is not to annoy the Swedes.

  10. Eric Says:

    Is global warming chemistry? Is Al Gore a scientist at all? Sure he won the peace prize on a loophole, but I often get the feeling that he has a very sketchy understanding of what he’s talking about, though the patter is familiar from much repetition.

  11. ronathan richardson Says:

    Could put Stubbe down under mechanistic enzymology. A bit of a stretch. But she’s been getting a lot of big awards recently. Not sure that’s a reasonable award topic though.

  12. Chemjobber Says:

    I think there’s a missing factor: controversy amongst the community. Supposedly, Lauterbur’s prize was delayed because the committee did not wish to stir up Damadian. (And lo, when they did grant the prize to Lauterbur and Mansfield, Damadian made quite a stir.)

  13. mskccheats Says:

    for a summary of ETHICS (and safety) concerns at a high profile cancer research center (and a purported nobel candidate’s lab), please see: http://www.mskccheats.blogspot.com or http://www.sloankettering.wordpress.com. craven self servitude … boo.

  14. Everyday Scientist » 2010 nobel predictions Says:

    […] Maybe this is the year I’ll (we’ll) make predictions for the actual Nobel. Paul at Chembark already started his predictions, and everyone else will be buzzing about it soon […]

  15. ChemBark » Blog Archive » The 2010 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, Part III: Revised Odds Says:

    […] (qualitative) criteria that went into assigning these odds were discussed in a previous post.  Results from old predictions were also discussed in a previous […]

  16. Gearing Up For Nobel Week | Newscripts Says:

    […] ChemBark’s post on Nobel Prize considerations […]

  17. Th' Gaussling Says:

    Whitesides or Breslow.

  18. ChemBark » Blog Archive » Predictions for the 2011 Nobel Prize in Chemistry Says:

    […] (qualitative) criteria that went into assigning these odds were discussed in a previous post.  Results from old predictions were also discussed in a previous […]

  19. StaudingersRide Says:

    Courts have ruled that Greg Winter’s antibody phage display patents are invalid. This leaves the Scripps patents as the only valid phage display patents in the antibody area. With dozens of drugs making their way towards approval based on this approach and the billions in sales from the phage antibody drugs humira, lucentis, and the coming sales of benlysta, it looks like Smith for peptide phage display and Scripps group on this one. Winter still has a chance for humanization though there is a list of characters there too.

    http://www.nature.com/nrd/journal/v10/n8/full/nrd3529.html

  20. Predictions for the 2012 Nobel Prize in Chemistry | ChemBark Says:

    […] (qualitative) criteria that went into assigning these odds were discussed in a previous post. Results from old predictions were also discussed in a previous […]

  21. Jere Williams Says:

    Superb blog you have here but I was wondering if you knew of any community forums that cover the same topics discussed in this article? I’d really like to be a part of community where I can get advice from other experienced people that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Appreciate it!

  22. Eusebia Caird Says:

    What’s up, all the time i used to check blog posts here early in the dawn, as i love to find out more and more.

  23. Andrea Minor Says:

    Now then, I’ve never really mentioned anything about fighting tactics but I’m sure by now you’ve realized that attacking as a party if you’re grouped together is great and a special attack is better. You can find it naturally occurring in caves where there is both lava and water, but this is extremely rare. At $20 a pop, this means that this cubed world that originally debuted on the PC in 2009 has made $60 million in just two and a half months.

  24. Ruthie Oliveira Says:

    What’s up to every one, the contents present at this web site are truly awesome for people experience, well, keep up the good work fellows.

  25. Ola Dean Says:

    Thanks for another magnificent post. Where else may just anyone get that type of info in such an ideal way of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I am at the look for such info.

  26. Frank Plowman Says:

    If you find a South Shore bedroom set that you love, don. For both kids and parents, this should be discussed on a serious note. The great thing about children’s bedroom furniture, is that is just a great way to really organize your child.

  27. Fallon List Says:

    I really like what you guys tend to be up too. This type of clever work and reporting! Keep up the fantastic works guys I’ve added you guys to my blogroll.

  28. mobile invoicing Says:

    s style, and they have done this by cautiously opting for
    the best quality materials in uninhibited prints and dyes.
    pdf, or a graphics file so you can then send
    it to your clients as an email attachment. In case you
    have encountered issues about the app, the developer of Guard Buddy would gladly respond to
    your questions.

  29. chris brown songs Says:

    Hey fantastic blog! Does running a blog like this take a great
    deal of work? I’ve absolutely no expertise in computer programming but I was hoping
    to start my own blog in the near future. Anyway, should you have any ideas or
    techniques for new blog owners please share. I know this is off subject
    nevertheless I simply wanted to ask. Many thanks!

  30. Lauren Byers Says:

    Hi colleagues, its fantastic post concerning tutoringand fully explained, keep it up all the time.

  31. Stefan McClemens Says:

    It’s hard to find well-informed people on this subject, however, you sound like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks

  32. Gregorio Kuntz Says:

    I’m amazed, I must say. Rarely do I encounter a blog that’s both educative and interesting, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. The issue is an issue that not enough folks are speaking intelligently about. I’m very happy I stumbled across this in my search for something concerning this.

  33. Ingrid Phillip Says:

    After checking out a number of the blog posts on your website, I really like your way of writing a blog. I bookmarked it to my bookmark webpage list and will be checking back soon. Take a look at my website as well and let me know your opinion.

  34. Jeremy Mcginnis Says:

    It’s really a cool and helpful piece of info. I am glad that you shared this helpful info with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

  35. Theron Cowper Says:

    He not just has affordable fees that are not based upon your selection in between a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13, but he has an outstanding BBB record and also a broad scope of experience behind him.

  36. Naomi Richer Says:

    It’s awesome in favor of me to have a site, which is beneficial in support of my knowledge. thanks admin

  37. Collette Triplett Says:

    Fishing for them was sluggish after that in the Coastline Haven Marlin & Tuna Club’s White Marlin Invitational Event.

  38. Sammie Charlton Says:

    While you have a contract with each of these companies, the fact that they see no prospect of getting any kind of money from Low Cost Holidays nullifies the arrangements you thought you had..

  39. Eve Torpy Says:

    The cardiologist will certainly do a full health examination on your pet dog and, based upon these preliminary findings, additional examinations will likely be suggested.

  40. Alisa Goins Says:

    Amnon Jackont (birthed 1948 in Ramat Gan) is an Israeli author of thrillers, a historian and also a literary editor.

  41. Jimmy Cochrane Says:

    hello!,I really like your writing so so much! share we communicate more approximately your article on AOL? I require an expert in this space to solve my problem. May be that’s you! Having a look forward to see you.

  42. Leigh Creighton Says:

    Flood insurance policy denotes the certain insurance policy coverage versus residential property loss from flooding.

  43. Camilla Reyes Says:

    In colder atmospheres with lower inbound water temperature level HPWHs might have to go briefly right into a back-up standard electric water home heating method to fulfill house warm water use in cooler months.

  44. Jessica Ruggles Says:

    Do you mind if I quote a couple of your articles as long as I provide credit and sources back to your website? My website is in the exact same area of interest as yours and my visitors would definitely benefit from a lot of the information you provide here. Please let me know if this okay with you. Thanks a lot!

  45. Juanita Wiedermann Says:

    Good day very cool blog!! Man .. Beautiful .. Superb .. I’ll bookmark your website and take the feeds also…I’m satisfied to find numerous useful info here in the submit, we want develop more strategies on this regard, thanks for sharing.

  46. Noah Gairdner Says:

    Puppy mill pups are vulnerable to congenital and also genetic conditions consisting of heart disease as well as blood as well as respiratory system disorders.

  47. Elliott Castles Says:

    The product on this website could not be duplicated, dispersed, sent, cached or otherwise utilized, except with the prior written consent of American City Company Journals.

  48. Karri Horst Says:

    It does have its very own scraper and will locate them in time based on the different impacts as well as search terms each project is filled with.

  49. Beatris Streeton Says:

    Please let me know if you’re looking for a writer for your blog. You have some really good posts and I believe I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d love to write some content for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please blast me an e-mail if interested. Regards!

  50. Damian Ricardo Says:

    Well, as it ends up, The golden state is among the most effective, otherwise the outright ideal state in the country for solar – and 2016 might be the very best year ever to get started.

  51. Salvatore Portillo Says:

    At Lilo we have decades worth of experience when it comes to providing website design and also advancement remedies for the London, Cape Town, Australian or worldwide market.

  52. Roderick Balfe Says:

    As a sugar child, all you require is to do things the wife seems not have time or power for, such as seeing to the movie theater, go cruising, go dancing, or perhaps relaxing for a night out in the town.

  53. Adam Mora Says:

    News4Jax found out a male was apprehended in Ohio on uncertainty of impersonating a legitimate roofing professional and taking money from home owners in Northeast Florida.

  54. Duane Curtiss Says:

    Agriculture could not play the function it once carried out in the Oklahoma economic situation, yet in country northwest Oklahoma, it still matters.

  55. Lorena Thurston Says:

    We likewise have a workplace in Oklahoma City as well as are proud to be servicing this location with a permanent staff and permanent office place for over five years.

  56. Hunter Selle Says:

    Southern Roof covering Center is pleased to supply quality building materials from these top produces to your jobsite in Georgia or Northern Florida.

  57. Kara Goldhar Says:

    Well because as humans we have the natural ingrained addiction to impulse buying. This often results in a very restrictive intake system which hurts both throttle response and power output. When using a plan online for some sort of slow computer fix the customer has the advantage.

  58. Audra Kitchen Says:

    We keep the highest possible airport terminal transportation requirements for Kansas City MCI flight terminal as well as we support our word.

  59. Luann Andronicus Says:

    Substitute Filters Made to Fit the Exfoliating Wands on Prize Skin’s Microdermabrasion Gadgets, Suching as MicrodermMD, RejuvadermMD, as well as the MiniMD.

  60. Chelsea Pike Says:

    Some light” treatment devices are actually just hand-held heating units for the skin.

  61. Klara Scholz Says:

    The Microderm MD is super simple with just a bit of technique, especially while using AUTO SETTING. It takes only 5 minutes to get back that smooth, radiant, and also younger looking skin that is simply below the surface area!

  62. Erna Null Says:

    Pueblo co most useful bots doesnt sync in order to. 2016 range investments influence how starting at $100 minimum first deposit online.

  63. Pasquale Kerry Says:

    Make certain to have a look at our Roller Skates Buyer’s Overview for much more terrific details from the beginner as well as newbie.

  64. Nelly Dey Says:

    A. Yes – benefiting Paradise Cat is completely as much as you – just allow us know if you need a break from your web cam modeling job or discover it’s not a great fit.

  65. Brand-relationshipmarketing Says:

    obviously like your web site but you need to take
    a look at the spelling on quite a few of your posts.
    Many of them are rife with spelling issues and I find it very bothersome to inform the reality
    on the other hand I’ll surely come back again.

  66. Jocelyn Handt Says:

    Some holistic health practitioners comply with a well-known custom, such as Typical Chinese Medication (TCM) or Ayurveda.

  67. Louie O'Callaghan Says:

    Maybe surmised that modern medication considers all natural healing beyond its orthodoxy, leaving the promo of healing to practitioners of aboriginal or different medicine 17– the nonscientific, nonmedical professionals explained by anthropologists.

  68. Terese Dozier Says:

    I would like to thank you for the efforts you’ve put in writing this website. I am hoping the same high-grade web site post from you in the upcoming as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to get my own site now. Actually the blogging is spreading its wings fast. Your write up is a good example of it.

  69. Annetta Cota Says:

    At Silver Oak Gambling enterprise you will certainly have accessibility to play our on-line casino ready totally free.

  70. Meridith Arkwookerum Says:

    RESOURCE: National Nursing Home: Citizens might be counted more than once, depending upon their behavior and psychological issues.

  71. Arlie Cuellar Says:

    Quality posts is the main to invite the users to pay a quick visit the site, that’s what this site is providing.

  72. mäklare stockholm Says:

    mäklare+fast arvode+stockholm
    mäklare stockholm new york
    mäklare stockholms skärgård

    Its extracts could be diluted in warm water and then applied
    in the scalp two times a day. This can be a geometric design, floral pattern or seasons’ greetings.
    The five.1 system consists of seven speakers
    and a woofer.

    mäklare stockholm betyg
    arvode mäklare stockholm 2013
    mäklare stockholms skärgård

  73. Sara Watters Says:

    Our leading SEO Business offers a Search Engine Optimization monitoring company in Warwickshire that is enthusiastic regarding achieving the very best SEO results for your service!

  74. Candice Wexler Says:

    . Sober house operators would certainly be called for to provide 48-hour notification of eviction or give alternative sanctuary to renters in an effort to stop homelessness.

  75. Dieter Garden Says:

    We want you to see us as your trusted internet marketing companion, working together for your long-term service success.


Leave a Reply

*